ZCC reviews code recommendations from Council; homes in on final issues
ZCC Special Session
At a special session of the Zoning Code Commission, chairman Alan Greenberger led a discussion about City Council Resolution No. 110741, which recommends 40 amendments to the draft zoning code. The commission focused on responses to 21 recommendations that had not been previously considered by the full group. The goal was to gain acceptance for as many responses as possible in order to prepare a final report by November 9 and keep the code on target for adoption in 2011. The ZCC was able to narrow the list of unresolved issues to six. The ZCC Work Plan Committee and the City Council zoning subcommittee will continue to work together to address concerns related to home occupations, group medical practices, existing overlay districts, group living, sky plane provisions, and uses in parks and open space.
Commission members are confident that none of the remaining issues will prevent the code from being approved by City Council. ZCC member and Councilman Bill Green agreed. “Council has had a very good working relationship with the Work Plan Committee this past month and we’ve made tremendous progress,” Green said. “We are hard-pressed to find any recommendation that gets in the way of the broader mission of the ZCC – producing a clear, transparent, predictable code that allows development.” Councilman Frank DiCicco added that although the resolution passed Council with a unanimous vote, some issues may need to be re-explained if the ZCC proposes a different change or remedy.
The ZCC could not reach immediate consensus on the remaining six issues, which will be discussed in further detail over than next two weeks. The commission wants to avoid the unintended consequence of regulating methadone clinics that could put up barriers to community wellness centers and clinics, for example, so did not fully accept Council’s recommendation. In the case of sky plane, some ZCC members agree with Council that the economic impacts of the provisions have not been fully tested, while others think the new massing requirements are a powerful and well-reasoned tool that will increase design opportunity. And existing safeguards against oversaturation of uses and uses that may be deemed a nuisance must be maintained in a way that does not discriminate or undermine revitalization efforts.
The timeframe for resolving these issues is tight. The ZCC must take a final vote on the amended draft of the code at its next regularly scheduled meeting on November 9. City Council must then introduce the code and master ordinance on November 17 so that a public hearing on the final report can be held December 5 and a final action by City Council can take place on December 15, the last session in 2011.
To view the October 26 PowerPoint presentation on changes, click here.
Zoning Watch 2011 Archives
ZCC
- 12/15/2011 City Council gives Philadelphia a new zoning code     (Current)
- 12/07/2011 Committee sends zoning code bills to Council for final vote     (Current)
- 11/17/2011 Bill to replace current zoning code is introduced into Council     (Current)
- 11/15/2011 PCPC recommends approval of zoning bill 110766 with conditions     (Current)
- 11/09/2011 ZCC votes unanimously to send Final Report to City Council     (Current)
- 10/26/2011 ZCC reviews code recommendations from Council; homes in on final issues     (Current)
- 10/20/2011 Zoning reform gets one step closer as City Council passes resolution of code recommendations     (Current)
- 10/12/2011 ZCC discusses Council recommendations to date; awaits formal resolution of requested changes     (Current)
- 09/27/2011 Council closes hearings on draft zoning code; on track for vote in 2011     (Current)
- 09/21/2011 Zoning forum addresses how to resolve final issues and prepare the code for adoption this year     (Current)
- 09/14/2011 Hearing on draft code draws crowd     (Current)
- 09/08/2011 Councilmembers Share Concerns with ZCC at Briefing     (CurrentCurrent)
- 07/19/2011 Next Great City Coalition Launches E-Petition to Pass Updated Zoning Code     (Current)
- 07/15/2011 Fact sheets highlight why zoning reform is so important     (Current)
- 07/08/2011 ZCC offers property research service     (Current)
- 06/15/2011 City Council commences hearings on zoning code     (Current)
- 06/08/2011 ZCC waits for Committee hearings to begin; work continues on sign controls and tools to aid public understanding     (CurrentCurrent)
- 05/11/2011 ZCC VOTES YES! Draft code moves to City Council, but threat remains     (CurrentCurrent)
- 05/09/2011 10 MORE YEARS TO ZONING REFORM?     (Current)
- 05/03/2011 Final X-Change focuses on parking     (CurrentCurrentCurrent)
- 04/27/2011 Stakeholders weigh in on development standards and how to encourage good design     (CurrentCurrentCurrent)
- 04/19/2011 Stakeholders discuss new dimensional standards     (CurrentCurrent)
- 04/13/2011 Vote to send draft code to City Council May 11     (Current)
- 04/05/2011 Stakeholders focus on new use categories     (CurrentCurrent)
- 03/23/2011 ZCC “Stakeholder X-Changes” underway     (CurrentCurrent)
- 03/17/2011 At-large Council candidates support new zoning code     (CurrentCurrentCurrentCurrentCurrentCurrent)
- 03/16/2011 ZCC “Stakeholder X-Change” draws crowd     (CurrentCurrent)
- 03/02/2011 ZCC delays sending zoning code to City Council for 10 weeks     (CurrentCurrentCurrent)
- 02/28/2011 ZCC explains how decisions about the new code were made     (CurrentCurrentCurrent)
- 02/22/2011 Vote scheduled for March 2     (current)
- 02/18/2011 Special meeting lets ZCC explain how decisions about the new code were made     (current)
- 02/15/2011 ZCC adds two public meetings to schedule     (CurrentCurrent)
- 02/09/2011 ZCC delays vote on new zoning code; some question whether code is ready for City Council     (Current)
- 02/03/2011 City Council voices concerns about new zoning code     (Current)
- 02/03/2011 Updated “Referral Draft” is released     (Current)
- 01/26/2011 February 9 vote on draft zoning code questioned as revisions continue to be made     (current)
- 01/26/2011 Building Industry Association comments on December 2010 draft zoning code     (current)
- 01/26/2011 February 9 vote on draft zoning code questioned as revisions continue to be made     (CurrentCurrent)
- 01/26/2011 Building Industry Association comments on December 2010 draft zoning code     (CurrentCurrent)
ZBA
General Zoning
- 03/02/2011 Zoning Basics     (CurrentCurrent)
Zoning Maps
- 03/02/2011 Philadelphia Zoning Maps     (CurrentCurrent)